Space Jam, Dunkaroos, Gossip Girl, the Motorola Razr—these days, it seems like everything is getting a reboot, remake or revival. The trend might appear to some as creatives and brands lacking fresh ideas or mitigating risk by banking on past popularity to fuel future success, but it goes deeper than that.
Our current cultural landscape is steeped in nostalgia, a wistfulness for aspects of our pasts.
In challenging, uncertain times especially, we cling to familiarity, comfort and what we recall from the “good old days.” It’s no surprise that during a global pandemic, nostalgia marketing is all the rage.
More often than not, the feeling of nostalgia clings to positive memories, so when a brand, event or product is a part of that memory, they’re at an advantage.
Campbell’s soup making a return for dinner prep this week. Bringing back alllll the comfort foods of my childhood. Mushroom chicken. Army food goulash. Casserole.
Classic 80’s and 90’s dishes that taste like home. pic.twitter.com/mtLopGXkcA
— Scarlet in the Realz. (@MissScarFever) May 11, 2021
If my hair was tested, I’m sure they’d detect Campbell’s tomato soup and Kraft Singles from a childhood worth of that. #Classic
— Combat Artist (@CombatArtistBJJ) September 28, 2020
When used correctly, nostalgia marketing is an effective way to excite, inspire brand affinity and give people a warm fuzzy feeling they won’t forget. Here are five ways to get it right.
1. Tune into the nostalgia melting pot on social media
When I was a young middle schooler, newly obsessed with makeup, Maybelline’s Dream Matte Mousse foundation was a prominent fixture in my life. More than a decade later, thanks to the resurgence of the Y2K aesthetic powered by social media creators and influencers, the foundation found its way into my timeline, and back into my heart.
This isn’t an isolated event. Social media is a melting pot of nostalgia where you can reminisce and feel connected to a larger community of people with shared interests. Social is swirling with conversations and content about what consumers miss from the past, the memories that bring them back to their childhoods and the brands that left a mark along the way.
When marketers use social listening to stay tapped into social conversations about their brand, they can capture and capitalize on moments when people are reflecting on your brand’s legacy. For example, Maybelline might use the modern Dream Matte Mousse moment to reminisce with their audiences or jump in to highlight their new and improved formulas.
2. Focus on audience and relevance
To effectively use nostalgia marketing in your strategy, brands need to understand what resonates with their audience. What makes one person nostalgic, could make another person feel out of the loop. Age, interests, historical events and more influence what we hold dear.
On the surface, nostalgia marketing seems to narrow the audience you’re able to target. But at its best, it can get your brand and legacy in front of new audiences.
To celebrate the 50th anniversary of its Monster Cereal brands, General Mills created a new Monster Mash cereal that combines old favorites like Count Chocula, Boo Berry and Franken Berry, and the previously discontinued Frute Brute and Yummy Mummy. In addition to the cereal, the campaign launched with a remake of the 1962 hit song “Monster Mash” available on Spotify and a behind-the-music mockumentary. Plus, a special QR code on the cereal boxes redirects to “The Remaking of the Mash” homepage.
With this approach, the campaign targets a spectrum of audiences and gives nostalgic parents a fun way to introduce the cereals to their own kids.
Who needs milk when I have Tears of Joy!
— Andrew Dunn (@drewpdogg99) August 16, 2021
3. Reintroduce products back by popular demand
Shopping trends and consumer preferences continuously change, which is why many brands frequently discontinue and launch products. But when a favorite or go-to product disappears and is no longer available for purchase, people frequently share their disappointment on social.
With social listening, brands can take stock of the products that people miss. If the conversation is large enough, you might even consider bringing a discontinued item back to surprise and delight customers.
It’s been like 3 years and honestly I’m still not over the fact that @mcdonalds got rid of Orange Hi-C
— Molly Marie (@MollyOhhdonnell) July 29, 2019
For years, people begged McDonald’s to bring back Hi-C® Orange Lavaburst®, a drink that first appeared on the menu in 1955. The fast-food brand’s social media manager, overwhelmed by fans’ passionate pleas, used social listening to create a fan-driven pitch to put the drink back on the menu. At long last, Mcdonald’s said, “We hear you and we ‘C’ you.”
Hi-C Orange Lavaburst is *officially* back at participating McDonald’s
— McDonald's (@McDonalds) June 1, 2021
4. Embrace the #TBT
On August 12, 2021, the MLB hosted a Throwback Thursday treat—for the first time ever, two major league teams, the Chicago White Sox and the New York Yankees, faced off at the site of the legendary 1989 baseball movie, Field of Dreams. Everything about the evening evoked nostalgia, from Kevin Costner and the players emerging from the cornfields accompanied by the tender movie score to the throwback uniforms. It paid off.
The #MLBatFieldofDreams was the most-watched regular season baseball game in 16 years, with 5,903,000 viewers across FOX and FOX Deportes ⚾️
Chicago and New York ranked as the top two markets, and it was the most-streamed regular season baseball game in FOX Sports history 🌽 pic.twitter.com/EfzfrUUik2
— FOX Sports PR (@FOXSportsPR) August 13, 2021
In addition to being the most-watched regular season baseball game in 16 years, the Field of Dreams game was the most in-demand regular season game for Vivid Seats. The official ticket vendor reported that the average price for a ticket was $1,176. If you build it…they will come.
The Field of Dreams game made this Millennial feel like a kid again, but you don’t need to go that big to evoke nostalgia.
People love a #TBT moment, as evidenced by the more than 577 million Instagram posts that include the hashtag. Businesses can join in and share throwbacks of their own. Archival video footage and photos make for fun, retro-tinged social content while also serving as a reminder that your brand has staying power.
— Genesee Brewery (@GeneseeBrewery) August 12, 2021
#TBT or self-reflective posts can also be an endearing way to show how far you’ve come. Remember all the “how it started vs. how it’s going” memes that emerged in 2020? They became a simple, charming way for both individuals and businesses to demonstrate growth or change, and you don’t have to have a long brand history to create your own version.
5. Don’t force it
It might seem like a reboot means that there’s an automatic, built-in audience, but it also comes with risks. Nostalgia is an emotional experience that makes us feel bonded to our longtime favorite and iconic brands, products, music, movies, etc. These things are precious to us, so if it’s redesigned or repurposed in a way that fans aren’t receptive to, you will hear about it.
Nostalgia marketing is a tactic, not a long-term business strategy, so don’t try to force it. If your business is new and tied to being modern, fresh and innovative, market it that way. Look forward and capitalize on emerging trends rather than trying to draw on the past for inspiration.
Keep listening to your customers
Want to know what makes your audience nostalgic, what challenges they have that your product solves or what kinds of content they want to see more of from your brand? Start listening.
Best-in-class brands listen to the voice of the customer (VoC) to make strategic, data-driven business decisions. Download this guide to learn how to harness VoC data and uncover a potential nostalgia marketing opportunity today.
The ultimate guide to evaluating influencer media kitsPublished on September 21, 2023 Reading time 7 minutes
Social media marketing: What it is and how to build your strategyPublished on September 20, 2023 Reading time 22 minutes
The importance of social media marketing: 7 stats that prove social’s role in business successPublished on September 18, 2023 Reading time 7 minutes