Our team also builds amazing social media management software. Try it FREE for 30 days.

Why Facebook Groups Are a Poor Choice for Business

You might have noticed that Facebook recently rolled out a totally new version of its “Groups” feature. Just like their predecessors, the new Groups are not ideal for small businesses looking to engage with customers.

Many small business owners relied on the old Groups to promote their products and services, but even then they were operating at a disadvantage.

There are some small ways you can use Groups to reach people, but Facebook’s Pages feature should be your primary engagement tool. That’s the way Facebook intended it, and here are a few practical reasons that Groups won’t cut it.

1. Groups Are Created By the Public, Not You

Groups are intended to emerge organically out of existing social relationships. People add their friends, colleagues or family members to groups like “Johnson Family,” “Class of ‘92,” or “Entrepreneurs.” As such, they’re only rarely created around a brand, and most Facebook users would write off any Group created under that pretense.

Facebook did this to make its social network better mirror the informal and largely unspoken social networks of the real world. It’s a departure from the old Groups system, which has now been deprecated.

Some of the old Groups still exist, but you can’t create Groups in the old style anymore — and it’s just as well, because those were never intended for brand promotion or customer engagement either, even though many business owners tried to use them that way.

2. You Have Limited Control Over Groups

Even if you’re the original creator of a Group, your options are limited. You can add people to the Group, but you can’t do anything besides post messages on its wall from an existing profile and add brief description text, sans outside links.

You can’t add more detailed information about your business, and you don’t have any customization options to show would-be customers or clients what you’re all about. Furthermore, you have to already be Facebook friends with someone to promote the Group to him or her.

Again, Groups are communal. They don’t offer any tools or special privileges to promoters or business owners.

3. There’s No Analytics Tool for Groups

You’ll need information about how your target audience is finding your promotional content, how much they’re engaging with it and which promotions work best or worst to reliably generate results with social media. Groups don’t offer any services to help you there.

Furthermore, few if any third-party applications for tracking engagement or managing social media presence offer analytics tools for Groups, in part because Facebook does not make much of the needed information public as it does with Pages, which we’ll discuss in a moment.

Without that data, you’ll be flying blind while you’re trying to reach your target.

Pages: The Best Choice for Facebook Engagement

Even though Groups won’t meet your needs, Facebook has something that will. Pages are designed specifically for brand promotion, with built-in analytics, customization options and advanced controls for presenting your case to customers and clients.

Users can “Like” a page to receive updates about it and place it on their profiles for all their friends to see. Their decision to Like the page is immediately broadcast to all their friends, though they can choose to remove that update after it’s been sent out.

That broadcast exposes you to their friends; consider it a sort of endorsement. It’s automated word of mouth. That doesn’t happen when a Facebook user is added to one of the new Groups.

You can upload videos, photos and applications, host discussions with online forums, and even host events in the Page’s name and account — all things you can’t do with Groups.

Facebook’s written an introductory guide to creating your Facebook Page, so check that out for more details.

[Image credit: Terry Ross]

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
wernerkeil 5 pts

Yes, they became a pain, even more recently, as the "Share with" feature for FB pages seems broken for most groups. It just isn't possible to share a page with a group, you need to navigate to that URL, copy it and paste it into the group. Works fine, so the message "your credentials are insufficient" is bullshit, it's just the FB-internal way that has a bug here;-/

It is a shame that Facebook pages are so difficult to design nicely for most people. But for brands they are almost manna from heaven, many are pointing you here rather than their own websites for obvious reasons...metrics, engagement, exposure.

Hiya
I'm afraid I have to respectfully disagree with you. My group started just a week ago, because it was like minded people who joined it, they, in turn invited their friends who invited some of their friends etc and now I have a massive 667 people!! That is almost double what my page was!
I'm not sure if this is an exception but I wouldn't say a FB group is a poor choice entirely! I do think your disadvantages are spot on, and all but a little point I think you pretty much covered this subject educationally....of which I've learnt a lot I didn't know!! :)
Thank you

Facebook Pages are also likely going to be the platform of choice for Facebook and third party developers going forward.

Facebook is also notorious for pulling support from once popular platforms (ie: FBML) so keep an eye on FB Groups. If it looks like Facebook is moving away from supporting Groups, make the leap into a Facebook Page so you don't get caught out in the cold.

Thanks for your comment TBH!

- Don

Hey, Samuel. I think you make some great points about some of the disadvantages of using a Facebook Group to engage your customers (particularly the lack of analytics), but I do think you miss an important opportunity.

For example, a photography shop could create/moderate a group for local photography hobbiests and pros to share tips, asks questions, or just chat. Of course, if a group already exists, it's better to just join that group and participate; but overall I think it's better if you're can be the first to create the group.

The key is to make it about the community and be an active, supporting member of it.

Also, although it's a bit technical, the OpenGraph API does allow access to groups, which means a custom analytics tool could be developed to monitor and measure group discussions.

Thanks for your comment Dagan. With Facebook's recent changes to the functionality of Facebook Pages (making then behave more like personal pages) it seems redundant to spend time on Facebook Groups.

Although Groups tend to be fan generated and moderated, a good social campaign to move the fans of a Group over to your Facebook Page may be a more effective use of your resources as opposed to maintaining a platform that may eventually go the way of the dodo.

Thanks again for your comment!

- Don

I dont like our reliance on Facebook for engagement of any sort. Unfortunately, its a standard for now.

My friend is creating his own Facebook like community using Buddy Press and I think more and more people will continue to do that.

From the perspective of a biz its prob a better choice IF they can pull it off.

It helps if the community (on Facebook or otherwise) is organized around the same cause and has higher targets in mind, rather than simple profit. Im talking about altruism built into the biz model but I feel like now Im getting off track..lol sorry.

Good post. Ive noticed this change with FB group and Im not a fan. One feature I miss is the ability to send an email to all members. It kinda sucks.

Hey Dino!

Your friend must be like David with a stone aimed at Facebook. I suppose it's possible to topple a giant but you'd better have a good reason to do so.

I think many more millions of people will be flocking to Facebook for the foreseeable future before it ever starts to show signs of diminishment. There is still a compelling reason for businesses to have a presence there even though we all know the Internet seems to float of a sea of desire for the 'next best thing'.

Thanks for your thoughts!

- Don

Trackbacks

  1. [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by SproutSocial Blog. SproutSocial Blog said: Why Facebook Groups Are a Poor Choice for Small Business http://bit.ly/NoFacebookGroups #Facebook #Pages [...]

  2. [...] New style Groups you’ve created/joined – open, closed, [...]

  3. Check This Out…

    [...]once I saw this site I just had to let the world know, they got a good thing going[...]…